Sheesh, my bad - but where does it fit then, this poor, homeless, yet interesting thread? Hardly in Questions and Guides either I reckon. Oh well, we'll let Alph decide where he wants to move it to next
I'd put the original q the other way round. Why did the CSs die in the other attacks? When I use the simulator the CS never seems to get sunk in an attack.
If it doesn't agree with the simulator then I'd call it a bug. If it agrees, but is a surprising result then that's just a game feature, like some of the other anomalies that have been discussed before and elsewhere.