Sheesh, my bad - but where does it fit then, this poor, homeless, yet interesting thread? Hardly in Questions and Guides either I reckon. Oh well, we'll let Alph decide where he wants to move it to next
OMG, as soon as the thread escapes the holy grail AKA my bugsection, it starts to drift off into meaninglessness with non-constructive posts. Someone help!
I'd put the original q the other way round. Why did the CSs die in the other attacks? When I use the simulator the CS never seems to get sunk in an attack.
If it doesn't agree with the simulator then I'd call it a bug. If it agrees, but is a surprising result then that's just a game feature, like some of the other anomalies that have been discussed before and elsewhere.