Rate the Player Above

prolong

Guest
BP - 9/10
Alliance - 10/10
Rep - 9/10
Points - 9/10

Total: 37/40 ;D
 

SamuraiDragon

Guest
dude?

Its says BP and seeming im around rank 30 fighter i think i deserve more than 6/10? regarding alliance 5/10 seems a bit harsh?

Sorry for the rant but it annoyed me...
I saw ur rank before posting but ur dbp is x2 ur abp
ur alliance is nearly dbp x2 abp
but it's nothing personal

if it makes you feel any better I'll re-rate you . . .

Nivrap402:
BP- 8/10
Alliance- 8/10
Rep- 8/10
Points- 8/10

Total- 32/40 point
(u got 5 extra points)
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Brimzues

Guest
SamuraiDragon:
BP- 5/10..both ABP and DBP seem a bit low
Alliance- 9.0/10 no one is perfect
Rep- 8/10
Points- 7/10..maybe the multiple alliance changes held you back a bit

Total: 29/40

edit :typo
 

prolong

Guest
Brimzues
BP- 10/10 Rank 16 wow
Alliance: 10/10 Best alliance
points: 10/10 Rank 28 better than me
Rep: 9/10

Total: 39/40 your nearly perfect ;)

Prolong:
BP- 8/10
Alliance- 8/10
Rep- 8/10
Points- 8/10

Total- 32/40 point
(u got 5 extra points)
Hehehe ;) thx
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Satanorr

Guest
Prolong
BP - 8/10
Alliance - 9/10 ( Docked a mark for turning colours to dues)
Points - 6/10
Rep - 5/10 never came across you personally but from what I see you are good :)


Total: 28/40
Skully: Added in the total for you ;)

 
Last edited by a moderator:

Satanorr

Guest
I play under a different Alias, I don't think he would be able to rate me :p
 

Skullyhoofd

Guest
Ah, Well then I take back my post (unless you are willing to give your in-game name) :p

Next one rate Chilluminati! :D
 

Satanorr

Guest
I will when everyone hates me :p

Chilluminati

BP - 9/10
Alliance - 4/10
Points - 6/10
Rep - 8/10 I like your posts in forums (sometimes ;) ) But again, never came across you.

Total - 27/40
 

rooibaard

Guest
And so the cycle perpetuates!

Satanorr

BP - 0/10 Can't be that good if you are incognito.
Alliance - 0/10 must be a shy alliance.
Points - 0/10 no point
Rep - 1/10 you are participating here so you get a point.

Total - 1/40
 

Satanorr

Guest
My ingame name is mesomike, I haven't said before because I've talked to a few players that have just laughed at me because I just started again on Ithaca even though I have suffiecient experience :)

Do I have to rate you now? :(
 

KillerPoodle

Guest
I'll just rate you, and we can keep the cycle going :)

For mesomike

BP - 4/10 (I'm kind of using your Psi account as a base line here, your Ithaca account doesn't really tell us much :p)
Alliance - 11/10 (Any hair-related alliance is an alliance worth joining in my opinion)
Rep - 5/10 (I haven't come across you, so I can't really judge yet)
Points - 4/10 (Once again I'm hoping that this account becomes as good as your Psi account)

Total = 24/40
 
Last edited by a moderator:

KillerPoodle

Guest
Whoops, forgot rooibaard rating as well:

BP - 9/10
Alliance - 8/10 (I still think that AA's alliance 'Im a Banana' could wipe the floor with you guys ;) )
Rep - 5/10 (Never really talked, so yet to form an opinion)
Points - 9/10


Total = 31/40
 

nivrap402

Guest
Killer Poodle:

BP- 8/10
Alliance- 7/10
Rep- 3/10
Points- 8/10

Total= 26/40

PS: Love your in game COA
 

prolong

Guest
Nivrap402

BP- 6/10 Poor ABP
Alliance- 9/10
Rep- 5/10
points- 9/10

Total: 29/40
 

Leneous

Guest
prolong
BP 7/10 - (see Note 1)
Alliance 8/10 - (see Note 2)
Rep - 8/10
points - 7/10
Total: 30/40

Note 1 - I'll have to disagree with people that say DBP need to be low and ABP high - i think ABP does need to be high - but having high DBP shows one of two things - you either are a turtle in a defensive alliance OR you are a team player and help everyone out. Thats not relating directly to you prolong - just saying in general. There needs to be balance here and DBP does not tell the entire story. If I ever say ABP 750,000 DBP 1,600 I would not want that player on my team. Same if I saw ABP 10,600 and DBP 65,000.

Note 2 - I feel very highly about DeB and it has my complete loyalty. There are some things I think need to change to give it a 10 rating again and I believe we will get there. (I feel like it should be 10/10 and my mind is telling me 8.5/10 but im going to round down because I know im bias)

PS - I tend to be insanely honest