none of them.. all are crap.
why? simple reason this is unwanted content.
any forum is designed to communication. Any signature above 64 or 128 letters or digits is unwanted content.
users looking here for solutions, answers ect.. not for a signature competition. This is one one reasons why I don;t use this place.
Usually users response in about 100 letters average.. so when you read forum, you see short answers and of course big signature. again and again.. pointless.
any serious forum disallow graphics signature. yeap.. this forum don;t look serious. IMHO.
with graphics signature we have:
- endless post per page,
- database must be fixed more often
- problem with "how to find solution" and navigation . for example: tread about CP - 26 pages right now. without graphics.. 6 pages is enough. So save space, time, emotions..
without graphics signature we have:
- forum works faster
- no problem to find what we looking for,
- healthy database,
- we save time, space, emotions.
I'm the owner 1,5 million users forum, so probably I know how this works.
It's pretty sad, when people responsible for support playing with such non important thing.
one more thing. this is IMO - no any answers in future.