Beginner SOTW #2 - Voting

Which one do you like best?


  • Total voters
    35
  • Poll closed .

dogukankurt

Guest
SOTW #2

Here are your entries:

1.

2.

3.

4.

5.



One of the entries was not accepted as it doesn't exactly fit the theme. So the maker of that can contact me by PM if they want to discuss.

Enjoy the great entries and may the best artist win!! :)
 

Thomas The Magnificent

Guest
Some are good, quite hard to pick though.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Skullyhoofd

Guest
Show us the disqualified one plz! :D

#3 gmv

#1 - Too bright imo.
#2 - Not bad, just feels too empty.
#3 - GMV.
#4 - Too dark.
#5 - Needs work on the blending.

Yes I did enter too :p
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Equanimity

Phrourach
1 GMV - Bar the text and the strange border, I like it.

2 - Blurry and doesn't really flow.
3 - Bad blending, no light source and no depth.
4 - My second favourite. The light source seems a little too big and a bit off putting.
5 - Not much to it.

(I didn't enter this week, ran out of time)
 

lawpaok

Guest
I love this comp!:D
3 tags tied for 1st place with 4 votes each!
 

dogukankurt

Guest
Sorry TTM I must've forgot to uncheck one of the boxes or something when I was putting the poll up. I was in a hurry when I put it up. At least we can see who votes so there can't be any double-voting.
 

dogukankurt

Guest
I had to go with 3 in the end. My top 3 were #3, #1 and #4...Bu I'm not liking the border on #1 so much even though I get it's supposed to look almost like a film reel which is quite original. As for #4 it would've definitely got my vote if it hadn't been so damn dark!! :) Overall #3 is the best one IMO...
 

lawpaok

Guest
I like how when 3 gets a vote and gets tied to 4 suddenly 4 gets a vote from someone as well...:p
 

Skullyhoofd

Guest
This is the most exciting sotw ever!

first 1,3 and 4 tied with 3 votes, then 1,3 and 4 tied with 4 votes, then with 5, then 3 and 4 were tied at 8 votes, then 4 was winning by 10 votes and now 3 and 4 are tied again!

This sounds confusing.
 

arul asveen

Guest
no you are confusing...
no.4 for me
i like his style the shades blah blah