DeletedUser
Guest
!!!!The Big Cobble Guide !!!!
Alright, so Cobble here, doing my last big guide. So, as many might know, I am the original Unit Comparer.., and my name is Cobble. You might know me from my land unit comparison, Hoplite vs. Chariot, or from my naval units, Bireme and Light vs. Trireme. If you don't know me, i like to make guides so that users are smarter in their unit choices, even if it means helping an enemy defeat me..
So below, i will be posting my 3 old guides, and 2 new ones, along with loads of new information and tactics. They will be the last guides i do, unless something spectacular happens.
NOTICE:WHEN READING MY GUIDES YOU DO NOT HAVE TO READ THE WHOLE THING. JUST READ THE OVERVIEW AND THE RESULTS OF COMPETITIONS. IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS ABOUT WHY I CHOSE WHICH UNITS FOR WHICH PURPOSE, OR WHY THIS UNIT IS BETTER THAN ANOTHER, THEN YOU WOULD READ THROUGH THE MATH OF THE COMPETITION
NOTICE:ALL 2.0 RELATED MATERIAL WILL BE IN BLUE!!!!!!
ANYTHING NOT IN BLUE CAN BE USED FOR BOTH 2.0 AND 1.26!!!!!!!!!
ALSO, FOR EASY BROWSING, CLICK ON DISPLAY MODES IN THE UPPER RIGHT HAND CORNER OF THIS POST, RIGHT NEXT TO RATINGS, AND CHOSE HYBRID MODE. THEN JUST CLICK ON THE GUIDE YOU WANT TO READ.
So.. without Further ado, in order.. My guides.
Here's the Menu for today
Page 1: Hoplite vs. Chariot
Page 2: Bireme & Light Ship vs. Trireme
Page 3: Manticore vs. Medusa
Page 4: Wall Spying
Page 5: Bireme vs. Fire Ship
Page 6: Overview
Page 7: Troop Numbers & Building Levels
Page 8: Tactics
Page 9: Gods' Spells & Battle Points
Page 10: Academy Research Guide
Page 11: Mythical Units
Page 12: Defensive LS
Page 13: Cobble's Personal Post
Page 14: 2.0 Farming
Page 15: Credits and Thanks
Oh and.. some music to listen to while you are reading
1.=2.=3.=4.=5.
_____________________________________________________________________________________
HOPLITE VS. CHARIOT
vs.
Now the question begs, which is better? The Hoplite or the Chariot? So i did some research and and all results will be in 5 categories: Time, Resources, Defense, Attack, and Speed & Farming
Background: Hoplites and Chariots are both Sharp units with good blunt defense. Hoplites take 1 farm space, when Chariots take 4. In order to compare equally, every test has to involve 4 hoplites since Chariots take up 4 farm spaces.
_________________________________________________________________
First contest: Time ( at Level 16 Barracks)
4 x 0:18:28 Hoplites = 1:13:53
1 x 1:17:07 Chariots = 1:17:07
Hoplites win
Second Contest: Resources
4 x (0 Wood) (75 Stone) (150 Silver) Hoplites = 300 stone and 600 silver
1 x (200 Wood) (440 stone) (320 silver) = 200 wood, 440 stone, and 320 silver
Hoplites win for overall resources needed
Third Contest: Defense
4 x 18b 12s 7d Hoplites = 72b 48s 28d
1 x 76b 16s 56d Chariots = 76b 16s 56d
Which results in the facts of: Chariot have +4B, Hoplites have +32s, and Chariots have +28d
Chariots win in blunt and distance, and Hoplites are best in defending against sharp (between Hops and Chars)
Fourth Contest: Attack
4 x 16s Hoplites= 64s
1 x 56s Chariots= 56s
Hoplites win for sharp attack
Fifth Contest: Farming & Speed
4 x 8 Hoplites = 32 carrying w/ 6 Speed
1 x 64 Chariots = 64 carrying w/ 18 Speed
Chariots carry twice as much at 3 times the speed
______________________________________________________________________
Overall:
Hoplites are faster to Train
Hoplites don't cost any wood, but Chariots save you some silver
Chariots are better to defend against blunt and distance, but Hops will knock out your sharp with their defense. Go for Chariots for defense
Hoplites Have a higher attack
Chariots best Hoplites at farming and movement
Individually, Chariots are better. But Farm space wise, Hoplites are your choice
(F)*Chariots are very good in the fact that they are emergency supply units. You can easily recruit them through a friends favor. In the situation of attack, a friend or alliance member can cast multiple amounts of chariots to help you out. They are quite fast, and good attackers. Speed is everything!*(F)
___________________________________________________________________
Situation
So lets say you have 50 hops, and 40 chariots. Do you attack with the 50 or the 40? You attack with the 40 chariots. Look at it farm space wise, not # wise. 160 (4 x 40) is better than 50 (hops) farm space. You have to realize the farm space, and not the actual #. So to correspond units, 40 chariots FS* is equal to 160 hops. The hops are better for Offense, and chariots for def.
So 40 chariots are better than 50 hops FS. But at equal FS, 160 hops will always be better than 40 chariots (40 x 4 = 160).
*FS= Farm Space
Page 1
Alright, so Cobble here, doing my last big guide. So, as many might know, I am the original Unit Comparer.., and my name is Cobble. You might know me from my land unit comparison, Hoplite vs. Chariot, or from my naval units, Bireme and Light vs. Trireme. If you don't know me, i like to make guides so that users are smarter in their unit choices, even if it means helping an enemy defeat me..
So below, i will be posting my 3 old guides, and 2 new ones, along with loads of new information and tactics. They will be the last guides i do, unless something spectacular happens.
NOTICE:WHEN READING MY GUIDES YOU DO NOT HAVE TO READ THE WHOLE THING. JUST READ THE OVERVIEW AND THE RESULTS OF COMPETITIONS. IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS ABOUT WHY I CHOSE WHICH UNITS FOR WHICH PURPOSE, OR WHY THIS UNIT IS BETTER THAN ANOTHER, THEN YOU WOULD READ THROUGH THE MATH OF THE COMPETITION
NOTICE:ALL 2.0 RELATED MATERIAL WILL BE IN BLUE!!!!!!
ANYTHING NOT IN BLUE CAN BE USED FOR BOTH 2.0 AND 1.26!!!!!!!!!
ALSO, FOR EASY BROWSING, CLICK ON DISPLAY MODES IN THE UPPER RIGHT HAND CORNER OF THIS POST, RIGHT NEXT TO RATINGS, AND CHOSE HYBRID MODE. THEN JUST CLICK ON THE GUIDE YOU WANT TO READ.
So.. without Further ado, in order.. My guides.
Here's the Menu for today
Page 1: Hoplite vs. Chariot
Page 2: Bireme & Light Ship vs. Trireme
Page 3: Manticore vs. Medusa
Page 4: Wall Spying
Page 5: Bireme vs. Fire Ship
Page 6: Overview
Page 7: Troop Numbers & Building Levels
Page 8: Tactics
Page 9: Gods' Spells & Battle Points
Page 10: Academy Research Guide
Page 11: Mythical Units
Page 12: Defensive LS
Page 13: Cobble's Personal Post
Page 14: 2.0 Farming
Page 15: Credits and Thanks
Oh and.. some music to listen to while you are reading
1.=2.=3.=4.=5.
_____________________________________________________________________________________
HOPLITE VS. CHARIOT
Now the question begs, which is better? The Hoplite or the Chariot? So i did some research and and all results will be in 5 categories: Time, Resources, Defense, Attack, and Speed & Farming
Background: Hoplites and Chariots are both Sharp units with good blunt defense. Hoplites take 1 farm space, when Chariots take 4. In order to compare equally, every test has to involve 4 hoplites since Chariots take up 4 farm spaces.
_________________________________________________________________
First contest: Time ( at Level 16 Barracks)
4 x 0:18:28 Hoplites = 1:13:53
1 x 1:17:07 Chariots = 1:17:07
Hoplites win
Second Contest: Resources
4 x (0 Wood) (75 Stone) (150 Silver) Hoplites = 300 stone and 600 silver
1 x (200 Wood) (440 stone) (320 silver) = 200 wood, 440 stone, and 320 silver
Hoplites win for overall resources needed
Third Contest: Defense
4 x 18b 12s 7d Hoplites = 72b 48s 28d
1 x 76b 16s 56d Chariots = 76b 16s 56d
Which results in the facts of: Chariot have +4B, Hoplites have +32s, and Chariots have +28d
Chariots win in blunt and distance, and Hoplites are best in defending against sharp (between Hops and Chars)
Fourth Contest: Attack
4 x 16s Hoplites= 64s
1 x 56s Chariots= 56s
Hoplites win for sharp attack
Fifth Contest: Farming & Speed
4 x 8 Hoplites = 32 carrying w/ 6 Speed
1 x 64 Chariots = 64 carrying w/ 18 Speed
Chariots carry twice as much at 3 times the speed
______________________________________________________________________
Overall:
Hoplites are faster to Train
Hoplites don't cost any wood, but Chariots save you some silver
Chariots are better to defend against blunt and distance, but Hops will knock out your sharp with their defense. Go for Chariots for defense
Hoplites Have a higher attack
Chariots best Hoplites at farming and movement
Individually, Chariots are better. But Farm space wise, Hoplites are your choice
(F)*Chariots are very good in the fact that they are emergency supply units. You can easily recruit them through a friends favor. In the situation of attack, a friend or alliance member can cast multiple amounts of chariots to help you out. They are quite fast, and good attackers. Speed is everything!*(F)
___________________________________________________________________
Situation
So lets say you have 50 hops, and 40 chariots. Do you attack with the 50 or the 40? You attack with the 40 chariots. Look at it farm space wise, not # wise. 160 (4 x 40) is better than 50 (hops) farm space. You have to realize the farm space, and not the actual #. So to correspond units, 40 chariots FS* is equal to 160 hops. The hops are better for Offense, and chariots for def.
So 40 chariots are better than 50 hops FS. But at equal FS, 160 hops will always be better than 40 chariots (40 x 4 = 160).
*FS= Farm Space
Page 1
Last edited by a moderator: