Are You Valid? - A Syllogism Game

[DeletedUser8396]

Hey everyone! I'm back with one of my creative, yet horrible, ideas.

The goal of this is for a user to post 2 premises of a syllogism, another user give the conclusion and propose two more premises, and then another user say if that user's logic is valid (and why), give the conclusion for the user above's syllogism, and give two premises himself.

Confusing? Good. Let me show you:

Spoiler

All crayons are sharp.
Some pencils are sharp.

Therefore some pencils are crayons.

My premises:

All pineapples are orange.
All pebbles are pineapples.

Your conclusion is invalid. Sharpness doesn't make it a pencil.

Conclusion to your premises: Therefore, all pebbles are orange.

My premises:

All crayons are sharp.
Some pencils are sharp.

The goal is to try and trick the user into making an invalid claim. Go ahead, give it a try. I swear it'll be more fun than it sounds! Btw, in case you're unfamiliar with this, the premises do not need to be accurate in order to be logically sound. Now, my premises:

All shovels are marine animals.
All marine animals are cute.

 

[DeletedUser36436]

All shovels are cute
(did I do that right??)

a pebble only posts horrible ideas,
This thread was posted by a pebble.

 

[DeletedUser40768]

Your conclusion is valid because all shovels are marine animals, which makes them cute.

Conclusion: A pebble posted a horrible thread.

A pebble is a rock.
Rock is a spammer.

Did I do this right?

 

[DeletedUser33530]

you didn't really make a conclusion, just changed the tense of what Genois wrote

therefore a pebble does exist

The story of Noah is true
Unicorns don't exist

 

[DeletedUser]

Noah is a Unicorn.


All CoD's smell bad
All things that smell bad are made in Japan

 

[DeletedUser]

Smelly CoD was made in Japan

Archon is cool
Cool is all.

 

[DeletedUser33530]

Archon lies

Pizza is delicious
The meaning of life is known.

 

[DeletedUser36436]

Your conclusion is valid as Archon cannot be everything.

Pizza is the meaning of life.

Bird poop is disgusting
Cows cannot fly

 

[DeletedUser8396]

Y'all do know the premises are supposed to be related, right?

 

[DeletedUser23986]

Your conclusion is valid as Archon cannot be everything.

Pizza is the meaning of life.

Bird poop is disgusting
Cows cannot fly

cows poop is still disgusting

premises should be related
relations can have issues

 

[Link of time]

Pebble is the only rational thinker that can manage to use country slang