Rate The Player Above

DeletedUser41523

Guest
The game is simple: Just rate the player above you based on the following.

Player:
Points: 0/10
ABP: 0/10
Total BP: 0/10
Reputation: 0/10
Overall: 0/40
 

DeletedUser54486

Guest
Player: The Smilodon Fatalis/The Kitten Fatalis:
Points: 8/10
ABP: 9/10
Total BP: 9/10
Reputation: 10/10
Overall: 36/40
 

DeletedUser53831

Guest
Player:Water732
Points:7/10
ABP:9/10
Total BP:6/10
Reputation:3/10
Overall:30/40
 

DeletedUser54495

Guest
Player: Isolated50
Points: 7/10
ABP: 9/10
Total BP: 8/10
Reputation: 7/10
Overall: 31/40
 

DeletedUser43070

Guest
Player: Kannerak
Points: 4/10
ABP: 4/10
Total BP: 3/10
Reputation: 2/10
Overall: 13/40

Can we also add
Alliance: X/10
 

DeletedUser53503

Guest
Player: Wheredevil
Points: 6/10
ABP: 6/10
Total BP: 7/10
Reputation: 7/10
Overall: 26/40

Busy with leadership instead of fighting I suppose.
 

DeletedUser41523

Guest
Player: Swagaliciousz
Points: 9/10
ABP: 10/10
Total BP: 10/10
Reputation: 6/10 (Didn't really know you prior to now)
Overall: 35/40
 

DeletedUser54486

Guest
Player: TheLastCrusader
Points: 9/10
ABP: 10/10
BP: 10/10
Reputation: 7/10
Overall: 36/40
 

DeletedUser1359

Guest
Thought I would revive this-

Player: Water732
Points: 4/10 - lost 2 big cities internally - seems a very infrequent player
ABP: 1/10 - No ABP in over a week - no signs of being an aggressive player
BP: 2/10 - No DBP in over a week - no signs of being an defensive player
Reputation: 1/10
Overall: 8/40
 

DeletedUser51499

Guest
richieup said:
Thought I would revive this-

Player: Water732
Points: 4/10 - lost 2 big cities internally - seems a very infrequent player
ABP: 1/10 - No ABP in over a week - no signs of being an aggressive player
BP: 2/10 - No DBP in over a week - no signs of being an defensive player
Reputation: 1/10
Overall: 8/40
Click to expand...

ouch
smiley_emoticons_lol.gif
 

DeletedUser31109

Guest
Player: Zibute
Points: 9/10
ABP: 8/10 Same for 3 days
Total BP: 8/10
Reputation: 8/10
Overall: 31.5/40
 

DeletedUser20914

Guest
player Electrico
logic: 0/10
loyalty: 0/10
Experience: 2/10
bluffer: 10/10
not keeping his promise to me, -10 points penalty
9+8+8+8=33 not 31.5 sucks at math -10 points penalty
df71bf9e44.png

Overall:-12/40
 
Last edited by a moderator:

DeletedUser20914

Guest
player: Scindo

Beast Mode:20/10
leadership:20/10
points:30/10
Reputation:20/10
Rome Total war:10/10

Overall:100/40
 

DeletedUser49022

Guest
Player: Electrico
Points: 7/10 - lost a city in the last month :(
Reputation: 9/10
Loyalty: 15/10
Experience: 9/10 - many points
 

DeletedUser54858

Guest
player: Strongside
points: 3/10 - pretty low considering time in the world
reputation: 3/10 - we're in different oceans, haven't encountered before
loyalty: 4/10 - 4 different alliances in 3 months, possible merger fails...
experience: 5/10 - modest greposcore, played a couple of worlds i'd guess

total: 15/40
 

DeletedUser4278

Guest
Player: klifford
Points: 6/10 not bad but not great either
ABP: 4/10 ABP rank below points rank so some minor point whoring going on. And in ocean 33/32 no less so not exactly the biggest competition needs work ;)
Total BP: 5/10 might seem harsh but is well below points rank
Reputation: 4/10 who?
loyalty: 11/10 Is in an alliance with an irritating leader who talks crap and then does not defend cities alliance itself is not great but has never moved so very impressive
Alliance: 4/10 from what i have seen looses cities easily little cordination and does not really own any oceans
Overall: 34/60

mediocre need to attack more and get into a better alliance
 

DeletedUser54661

Guest
I personally haven't played long enough to feel strong enough to rate another player. Total play time at this point in grep is maybe just under a year with a 3 year gap in the middle. But whatever... here goes. *note* he is in my alliance but I will hold not hold back.


Player: ianmiyster
Points: 8\10 - Rank 78 - 402151 points and 32 cities. Not bad man. Only thing I would point out is your city avg is 12,567 pnts. Might be alittle high for my liking.
ABP: 9 \10 - Rank 50 - 249661 points. Nice. Get into the top 25 and I'll upgrade you to 10 \ 10 :p
Total BP: 8\10 Rank 64 - 334417 Points - I know its hard to get DBP when your enemy tends to roll over and die, but come on man... even my defensive BP is higher
Reputation: 7\10 - While we didn't occupy the same space in the world when I was leading the wolves, I did know of you. You do have a presence here on the boards occasionally... and aren't a retard. However, not exactly a household name ;)
loyalty: 10\10 - Same alliance since early Feb. *shrug*
Alliance: 8\10 - Going to be completely honest and view my own alliance as an outsider looking in. Simmers are a very good bunch of seemingly hand picked players. Nice area coverage and seem to be able to focus and carry on multiple things at one time. Simmers only weakness... a lack of a core. There are some makings of one or two in 2 areas. This may need to be addressed before WW if we continue that long.
Overall: 50\60


Only advice... need to tighten up somewhere and also work on DBP ;)


With that being said... please rank me... hold no punches.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top