1. looks good, depth and lightening is very good!
2. looks nooby(no offense)
3. good one
4. more lighting would do the trick!
5. same as 2
6. The lighting is only on the sword
7. it just doesn't catch my eye
8. I feel that it would be better if it's lighting was reduced
the above comments are my opinion, im not a good artist but just telling my opinions.