Rate the Player Above

Osl112

Guest
A simple thread where you simply rate the player above you in different categories! After you have rated 5 categories out of 10, then you give them a total score out of 50.

The categories:
Points: /10 (Rate the number of points out of 10)
Opponents Defeated: /10 (Rate the players battle points)
Position: /10 (Rate the position of the player, dominance of the area)
Reputation: /10 (Rate reputation of the player, in game and on the forums)
Alliance: /10 (Rate their alliance; if he/she does not have one, ignore this section)

From those, you shall get a total.

Couple of rules though:
No going off topic. If you wish to discuss these ratings, please create a new thread.
Make sure you haven't left anyone out and don't rate anyone who just writes "Plz rate me", rate the person above who has rated another player
If you disagree with a rating, take it to PM.

Thanks... and go go go!
 

Roaring Whisper

Guest
Since he didnt list a player, ill start.

I want to know about: Roaring Whisper
 

fingolfin

Phrourach
Roaring whisper :
Points : 8/10 its better than mine but that dont mean much
BP: 6/10 its a good start but it could be better
Position: 9/10 hes the guy to fear on the rim
reputation: 10/10 the best there ever will be :p
Alliance 1/10 cos im not in it :D
 

Osl112

Guest
@Roaring Whisper, you don't have to name a player, you just need to rate the player above you...

Anyway...
Points: 5/10 Could do better in core
Opponents Defeated: 8/10 Excellent!
Position: 3/10 Need to strengthen up mate :p
Reputation: 3/10 Haven't heard of you at all :s
Alliance: 6/10 Ok, but you have some inactive players at the bottom

Total: 25/50
 

Roaring Whisper

Guest
(Im not on the rim)
fingolfin:
Points:2/10 For what its worth, I dont judge on points
BP: 8/10 GOOD ;)
Position:3/10 its gonna get heated there soon
Reputation: 5/10 Meh, ok
Alliance:7/10 Mysterious... o_O
 

ProX

Guest
Points: 5/10 - Poor in the grander scheme of things but not bad for your area, not a big fan of colonisation though, that will hamper your growth.

BP: 8/10 - Good in relation to your points, all attacking too which is nice :]

Position: 3/10 - You should be in the core!

Reputation: 7/10 - Good forum rep, need to back that up in game though.

Alliance: 3/10 - Yet to make a name for yourselves I think, and lots of competition in your oceans.

Total: 26/50
 

StokieScott

Phrourach
Points: 9/10 - Just outside the top 12 but looks like a possibility to gain access into it due to several of his cities can be nudged up

BP: 8/10 - Good overall BP with 3/4 of it being attacking however there is a healthy number defensive which shows h/she can attack but also knows how to defend their polis'

Position: 8/10 - From looking at your polis' it seems they are closish together so can support each other quickish aswell as swap resources and are close to other alliance members which would therefore help you out if you are under any heavy fire

Reputation: 6/10 - I have heard of you but seeing as you are a distance from oneself the reputation has yet to hit my shores, plus only seen you sporadically on forums

Alliance: 9/10 - Top points alliance with highest average aswell as third top BP and Third also in AP and still up there in 6 in DP (i'd only give 10/10 if you were top of everything im stingy like that ;))

Total: 40/50


Should be fun see if someone does me i think i'd be happy with 10/50 :p
 

RyanWard08

Guest
What a surprise osl made a ratings thread:p

Points: 5/10 Ocean taken into account
Opponents Defeated: 2/10 Pretty bad no matter your position
Position: 2/10 Too many alliance mates on your island.
Reputation: 2/10 Never heard of you
Alliance: 2/10 Never heard of them

13/50
 

TT01

Guest
on ryanward

Points: 8-9/10 Ocean taken into account being a core ocean, harder ground
Opponents Defeated: 8/10 doing preety well
Position: 8/10 sat in the core, some big enemys around,
Reputation: 9/10 who ever played on zeta herd of the dobby and ryan war :p also on epsilon with the melons
Alliance: 10/10 your my boss and its JUST FOR LAUGHS

43-44/50
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Snagglepus

Guest
Points: Too lazy too look >.<
Opponents Defeated: JFL kicks some major butt so 8/10
Position: 9/10 Core area...tough
Reputation: 10/10 Who hasn't heard of TT01
Alliance: 8/10 Like I said...JFL kicks butt ^^
 

Roaring Whisper

Guest
Points: 6/10
OD: 7/10
Position: 6/10
Reputation: 3/10 *Snagglepus is an unknown quantity at this point* :p (But I still love ya :D )
Alliance: 9/10 Imperial Guard appears to have their act together
 

Setamdar

Guest
Points: 4/10 (why a colony, esp on the rim?)
BP: 3/10
Position: 5/10
Rep: 5/10 (good theta informer post, but likes to spamalot)
Alliance: 4/10 (not an MRA, but not particularly good either)

21/50
 

OrangeOpti

Guest
Points: 9/10 Pretty good, top 100.
BP: 9/10 Again, nice, top 100
Position: Ehhh, in what?
Rep: 0/10 Never heard of you
Alliance: 10/10 we all love laughs!

38/50 :D
 

Vork

Guest
OrangeOpti

Points: 1/10 very low
BP: 1/10 you have bp, but only because you were attacked
Position: 1/10 your doomed :p lots of big fish near you.
Rep: 2/10 I've seen your name about
Alliance: 0/10 MRA :(

5/50
 

OrangeOpti

Guest
Lol - MRA, do you not make the connection between me and the fact that I am a spy. As for rep, havent been active lately and points/position - I don't play grepolis, I play the forums.
 

TT01

Guest
OrangeOpti

Points: 1/10 very low
BP: 1/10 you have bp, but only because you were attacked
Position: 1/10 your doomed :p lots of big fish near you.
Rep: 2/10 I've seen your name about
Alliance: 0/10 MRA :(

5/50
everyone knows orangeopti :eek:
well you should do.

go do you research next time lol
 

OrangeOpti

Guest
what he said! Do your research man...... I am orange for christ's sake.... Orange! One of the brightest colors out there!
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Gibbowo

Guest
Points:4/10
BP: 2/10
Position: 10/10 - Looks cozy there.
Rep 7/10
Alliance: -1/10 is a negative number possible?

aha :D

Cheers to you lad :)
 

Vork

Guest
what he said! Do your research man...... I am orange for christ's sake.... Orange! One of the brightest colors out there!
But I don't care to do my research on ya ;) some people have never heard of Jesus which is nice for them. But if they got asked, they would just say meh dno the dude :p

Anyway I rated you for game performance and it was fair, if it had been rate the forum personality I would have stayed clear of posting :)

Also no one rated me :(

 

TT01

Guest
i was only playing when i said go do your research :p

but ill do you now


Points: 9/10 smashing up theta with a world rank of 9
BP: 9/10 mainley all offensive, very good,
Position: 7/10 core, well placed to exspand where you want
Rep: 5/10 in game rep : ive not herd of you other than in theta or gamma but you do smash it up on both worlds. forum rep.: new to the forums i think ''/ or your just silent :D
Alliance:10/10 well wot can i say, your a team mate, so respect is due ;)