Well for me it came down to Pythagorus and Skully cause I've seen them both play and they are good at the game. I haven't seen the rooster or the cat play, nor have I really seen greg or gordon play, Osl and Eclipse are good but I haven't played with them for any period of time on a server. And the rest well......meh
Btw, why on earth is Cheezehead in this poll? I know he's nice and all but few people know him and he has been here a fraction of the time everyone else on the poll has.