Stats mean very little
, for instance BP can be obtained in many different battles.
Taking on one city with 2k undefended troops i.e. all attack trrops and no wall (some of the so called top players got their bp this way) is not the same as taking on a city with level 25 walls, tower and equivalent defensive troops.
Then there is the number of players, shogunate enclave had lots of players but were a very weak alliance. Smah bros were very strong but had less than 20 active members it would seem.
Then you have rouge players, is a player who is very strong but ignores the alliance rules a bennefit or a hindarance to the alliances strength?
That said its still fun to look at the stats ^_^ but its a shame most alliances are nothing but MRA's that cant organise even a defense let alone an attack.